Archive | Brodie Pk S.

UPDATED TO REFLECT NEW INFORMATION FROM SOCCER: Practice Spaces Available For Active Sports On Town-Owned Land: Supply Vs. Demand

UPDATED TO REFLECT NEW INFORMATION FROM SOCCER: Practice Spaces Available For Active Sports On Town-Owned Land: Supply Vs. Demand

Note: Article has been completely updated to take into account the additional data from soccer. [April 18, 10:30 p.m.]

After this article was originally published on Sunday evening, April 15, we received information from coaches of soccer teams regarding their practices held last Fall on town-owned properties (i.e. parks and schools). On Monday evening, the 16th, we received information from Rick Berneike, Soccer Co-President, which included practice schedules for soccer teams that had not been included in the information sent to Rec last fall.

Following is the additional information from Rick and below that information is an updated set of aerial views with the new information added. We are also including an updated summary which takes into account the new information.

As the writer of the article, I apologize for the confusion the article caused by my not having all of the relevant information available. This was not due to any ill-intent on anyone’s part, but I am sorry if I caused anyone grief, Maria.
____________________

Additional Information Submitted For Soccer

.
Maria, I’m sorry to have caused some confusion concerning this matter. Perhaps I can shed some light on the actual practice schedule for Rec Soccer during the Fall of 2011.

Per our conversation of last week when you called me to verify the information you had received from Dennis Minor (Rec Director), I was able to pick up a copy of the email I had sent him on Sept. 13, 2011. It seems that I had misinterpreted his question of when and where Rec Soccer’s practices would be held for the entire season as being a question of where and when practices would be held on a specific Friday (9/23). I can certainly see how this information could be construed as meaning that there is plenty of unused and available practice areas during the course of a week.

Here is the official schedule

Monday:

  • Bakerville school 5-7 pm

Tuesday:

  • Bakerville school 5-7 pm
  • Antolini school 5-6 pm
  • NH Elem 6-7 pm (2 teams)
  • Brodie north 5-7 pm

Wednesday:

  • Bakerville school 6-7 pm
  • Antolini school 5-7 pm
  • Brodie north 6-7 pm

Thursday:

  • Bakerville school 5-6 pm
  • Antolini school 5-6 pm (2 teams)
  • Brodie north 6-7 pm

Friday:

  • Antolini school 5-7 pm
  • Brodie north 5-7 pm

As you can see, the available spaces are pretty well used all week long.

The major differences in venue use from any given year to the next has more to do with coaches preferences except for the K-1 division. They all practice at Bakerville school because of the small field size and restrictions mandated by the school.

I hope this information is helpful.
I do believe that with patience, understanding, and equal respect for all parties involved, keeping in mind that these parks belong to all the people of New Hartford, we will reach a long term solution to this current dilemma.

Repectfully,
Rick Berneike
Co-President New Hartford Youth Soccer

Updated Visuals Of Properties Available For Sports Practices

.
Ann Antolini School Sports Field

Aerial view of Ann Antolini School from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

New Hartford Elementary School Sports Field

Aerial view of New Hartford Elementary School from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

Bakerville School Sports Field

Aerial view of Bakerville School from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

Brown’s Corner

Aerial view of Brown's Corner from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

Brodie Park North

Aerial view of Brodie Park North from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

Brodie Park South

Aerial view of Brodie Park South from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

Analysis Of Use Of Practice Spaces In Summer/Fall 2011

.
When one looks at the updated practice data for the summer and fall of 2011, a very uneven picture emerges. Following is a breakdown of the number of practice hours per week at each field for each location:

  • Antolini School sport field: 7 hours per week (1 hr. x 2 since 2 teams were practicing at the same time);
  • New Hartford Elementary School sport field: 2 hours per week (1 hr. x 2 since 2 teams were practicing at the same time);
  • Bakerville School sport field: 6 hours per week;
  • Brown’s Corner sport fields: Hours not calculated since the whole park is used for practices and/or games;
  • Brodie Park North: 3 hours per field per week (6 hours divided between the two fields available);
  • Brodie Park South:
    • August: 25 hours per field per week (10 hours per week x 5 teams (4 football and 1 cheer) divided between 2 fields available);
    • September-mid November: 15 hours per field per week (10 hours per week x 5 teams (4 football, 1 cheer) divided between 2 fields available.

    Looking at the number of practice spaces available and the use to which they were put during the summer and fall of 2011, there appears to be a very adequate supply of space available to meet the needs of all active sports in town, even before the planned expansion of the Antolini sports field to provide more practice space. Friction that has arisen appears not to be due to the lack of practice space but rather to the manner in which the available space has been allocated by Youth Sports which did not appear to take into consideration the infrastructure available at each town-owned property.

    The cabin at Brodie North where Football's equipment is currently being stored

    Future Allocation Of Practice Space: Meeting The Needs Of Teams & Other Residents

    We believe that by using a rational approach, rather than an emotional one, in allocating practice spaces for the 2012 summer/fall season, the needs of the sports teams can be met while also respecting the needs of other users of the town properties as well as the needs of those residents who live next to or close to the areas in which active sports practices take place.

    It appears that the needs of the Football program are unique: We have been told that Football needs to have all their teams and the cheerleaders practice at the same time and at the same location, resulting in the need for parking for 50 or more vehicles. Unfortunately, Brodie South, where Football has practiced for the past 4 years, has parking available for approximately 12 cars. Brodie North, on the other hand, has parking for 100+ cars. We have also been told that Football has a lot of heavy equipment which the teams need to store on-site. While Brodie South does not have any storage available, Brodie North has cabins available for sports use. The cabin in the lower field adjacent to the Berkshire Hall parking lot is currently being used to store Football items (helmets, signs, etc.) while in the back of the cabin are stored the sleds which in the past were let out in the fields at Brodie South.

    In 2011 Football’s needs to have all their teams practicing together and storing their equipment on site could have been met had they been assigned the two practice spaces at Brodie North. In the upcoming season, the same is true. The only Football need that neither Brodie North nor Brodie South can accommodate is the Football program’s use of lights powered by a generator in order for them to continue practicing after dark. The use of lights can only be accommodated at the Antolini sport field; however, Football would then have to split their practices so that two teams would practice on 2 days and 2 teams would practice on three days, with the cheerleaders practicing in the area that has been used in the past as an obstacle course adjacent to the sport field. This would require Football to split its practices, just as every other sports program does.

    This appears to us to be a rational way to meet the current needs of our active sports programs. It would also take away the perceived urgency to improve the Antolini sports field, allowing us time to study the needs of Antolini School as a whole – and not just its sports field – once the impact of the closure of the Bakerville School becomes known.

    The cabin in the lower field at Brodie Park North where the Football program's equipment is now being stored. Photo: Maria Moore

    _______________________________________________________
    [PLEASE NOTE: We have received new set of practice schedules for Soccer for last Fall from Rick Berneike to replace the one originally submitted to Rec last Fall. We will verify the new set of schedules on Tuesday and will modify the visuals as appropriate. We apologize for the confusion which, despite our best efforts, appears to have occurred. Thanks for your patience; Monday 11:50 p.m.]

    [Clarification: This article covers the Summer/Fall 2011 use of town-owned lands for practices by Youth Sports programs. We did not include Spring practices since those didn't overlap with the Summer/Fall practice schedules; Monday, April 16; 10:20 a.m.]

    By: Maria Moore

    During the past year or so there has been a lot of discussion around the use of town-owned land by active sports, specifically surrounding the use of the field area at Brodie Park South by the Football program. Residents and park abuttors complained to the Rec Commission and to the town’s Selectmen that Football’s use was too intensive for the area, and they were told repeatedly that the use of that area by Football was driven by need – there simply was nowhere else that the Football program could be accommodated on town-owned land. With the new active sports season approaching and the practice area being allocated to Football pointing strongly towards the fields at Brodie Park South for the fifth consecutive year, we decided to look at the town-owned land that is available for use for practice by active sports and the extent to which that land was used by active sports in 2011 – in other words, carry out a supply vs. demand analysis.

    We obtained the 2011 practice schedules for soccer and baseball from the Recreation Department, and we confirmed those schedules with Rick Berneike for soccer and Sally O’Neill for baseball. Since the Football & Cheer schedules were not included in the schedules received from Rec, we asked for those schedules specifically and received an email from Steve Roth, President of Football & Cheer, outlining that program’s practice schedule.

    2011 Practice Schedules for Active Sports On Town-Owned Lands

    .
    According to the information we obtained, Baseball and most of Soccer practice took place at Brown’s Corner, the town park that is being used as athletics fields by active sports. The following is a listing of other town-owned lands available for active sports practices and the use to which they were put during 2011:

    • Ann Antolini School sports field:  Rec Soccer – Fridays, 5-7 p.m.
    • New Hartford Elementary School sports field: Unused
    • Bakerville School sports field: Unused
    • Brodie Park North open fields: Rec Soccer – Fridays, 5-7 p.m.
    • Brodie Park South open fields: Football & Cheer – (August) Monday through Friday, 6-8 p.m.; (September-mid-November) Tuesdays, Thursdays and Fridays, 6-8 p.m.

    Visuals With Dimensions Of Areas Available For Active Sports Practices

    .
    Following are aerial views of each of the town-owned properties with land available for practice by active sports. Each of the available areas has been shaded and the dimensions of the area have been added. Below the aerial views we have provided a link to download the views as a printable PDF.

    TOWN SCHOOLS

    Ann Antolini School Sports Field

    Aerial view of Ann Antolini School from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

    New Hartford Elementary School Sports Field

    Aerial view of New Hartford Elementary School from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

    Bakerville School Sports Field

    Aerial view of Bakerville School from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

    TOWN PARKS

    Brown’s Corner Athletics Fields

    No dimensions are provided for Brown’s Corner since the whole park is used by active sports.

    Aerial view of Brown's Corner from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

    Brodie Park North

    Aerial view of Brodie Park North from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

    Brodie Park South

    Aerial view of Brodie Park South from 900 m. Source: Google Earth

    Click the link to download Aerial Views Of Field Space Available For Active Sports Practice (22).

    Practice Spaces Available: A Need Well Met

    .
    From the above review of town-owned land made available to active sports for their practices, it seems that there is an ample supply of space available to meet the needs of all active sports in town, even before the planned expansion of the Antolini sports field to provide more practice space. The problem appears to be not in the amount of space available but rather in the manner in which the available space has been allocated by Youth Sports. Taking the data for 2011, it seems incomprehensible to have allocated two hours of practice per week to Rec Soccer at Brodie Park North while the Football program practiced at Brodie Park South for 6 to 10 hours per week according to the president of Football or for 12 to 15 hours per week according to those living close to Brodie South.

    The cabin at Brodie North where Football's equipment is currently being stored

    We have been informed that Football needs to have all their teams and the cheerleaders practice at the same time and at the same location, resulting in the need for parking for 50 or more vehicles. Brodie South, where Football has practiced for the past 4 years, has parking available for approximately 12 cars while Brodie North has parking for 100+ cars. We have also been told that Football has a lot of heavy equipment which the teams need to store on-site; while Brodie South does not have any storage available, Brodie North has cabins available for sports use – the cabin in the lower field adjacent to the Berkshire Hall parking lot is currently being used to store Football items (helmets, signs, etc.) while in the back of the cabin are stored the sleds which in the past were let out in the fields at Brodie South.

    We hope that as the coming season’s practice schedules are drawn up under the guidance of Rec, sports teams are given priority to areas that best meet their needs. Using the 2011 practice schedules, one could easily assign Rec Soccer to hold their two-hour Friday evening practice at New Hartford Elementary or the Bakerville School, leaving the two field areas and the green in front of Berkshire Hall available to the Football teams and the cheerleaders.

    In this way we can meet the current needs of our active sports programs while we take the time to study the needs of Antolini School as a whole – and not just its sports field – once the impact of the closure of the Bakerville School becomes known.

    The cabin in the lower field at Brodie Park North where the Football program's equipment is now being stored. Photo: Maria Moore

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.14 Comments

New Hartford Park Rules & Regulations Adopted By Recreation Commission; VIDEO ADDED

New Hartford Park Rules & Regulations Adopted By Recreation Commission; VIDEO ADDED

At last night’s Recreation Commission meeting the full commission discussed the draft Rules and Regulations submitted to them by the three-member Subcommittee that had been appointed to review and revise the town’s park rules; see our March 22 article 3 Rec Commission Members Appointed to Subcommittee….

Sign at Brodie Park South; the 'Sunrise to Sunset' sign has disappeared

After a careful discussion of the draft rules, the Rec Commission members voted unanimously to adopt the park rules submitted by the Subcommittee and as amended by the Commission members during their discussion. Those newly-adopted rules are the ones which now govern the use of all our town parks: Callahan Park, Chapin Park, Brown’s Corner and Brodie Park (both North and South).

The video of the April 4 Rec Commission meeting, including the Public Comments made by the close to 100 members of the public who attended the meeting, will be added to this article as soon as Bob the techie is able to process the video – look for it tomorrow, Friday.

The finalized copy of the new Rules and Regulations now in effect will not be available until the Rec Commission’s next meeting on Wednesday, May 2. NewHartfordPlus spoke with Rec Director Dennis Minor regarding the small changes made to the draft and below we are posting the draft rules with those changes where indicated by the yellow highlighting. Please note that the finalized Rules and Regulations may include slightly different wording from the changes indicated below. If you have any questions regarding the newly-adopted Park Rules and Regulations please contact the Rec Department by calling 860-379-3877 or emailing nhrecreation@town.new-hartford.ct.us.

Yellow highlights indicate where changes to the draft rules were made by the Rec Commission members before adopting the draft as the new rules and regulations

Changes To The Draft Rules

.
The following is a list of the changes (highlighted above) made to the draft rules by the Rec Commission members:

#3: Replace “Guest” by “Beach guests”;

# 7: Add “Barbecuing” before “Picnicking”

# 8: Add “Field House, Berkshire Hall” to the list of Athletic facilities;

# 10: Add “Owners must pick up waste.” after the first sentence;

#11: Change first sentence to read: “Parking is allowed in designated areas only.”

#12: A slight change in the wording to be made – unknown at this time;

# 16: Change “Alcohol”  to “Alcoholic beverages”;

# 17: Change “motorcycles” to “unregistered motorcycles”;

With just the few changes indicated above, these are now the newly-adopted Rules and Regulations governing all use of all New Hartford Parks. Download a copy of the Draft Rules and Regulations (without the highlighting in the copy of the rules above): New Hartford Park Rules and Regulations - adopted April 4, 2012 (24)

The Rec Commission members discussing the draft rules which they later adoptedx as their new Park Rules and Regulations. Photo: Maria Moroe

.

Rec Commission Meeting – Video And Summary

.
At their April 4 meeting, the Rec Commission members discussed the draft rules for the Town’s parks presented to them by their 3-member subcommittee. At the beginning of the meeting Chairman John Maschi welcomed the large crowd assembled in the Senior Center and then he invited those present who wished to give their input on the rules to do so during the 30-minute Public Comments section which was the first item on the agenda. Many members of the public took the opportunity to speak, with a large number of the comments addressing the Football program’s presence at Brodie South last year. Having given everyone the opportunity to comment, the Rec Commission members held their meeting, with the focus being discussion of the draft rules. They made minor adjustments to the language of the rules and then unanimously voted to adopt them as their new Rules and Regulations for Town parks.

Following is a video of the meeting.

Click the image above to view the video of the Rec Commission meeting on the NewHartfordPlus YouTube channel.

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.0 Comments

FOBPS Express Support For Rec While Revising Park Rules, Concern At Undue Pressure From First Selectman To Allow Football’s Self-Made Rules Of Use At Brodie Park South: Copy Of Letter To Residents

FOBPS Express Support For Rec While Revising Park Rules, Concern At Undue Pressure From First Selectman To Allow Football’s Self-Made Rules Of Use At Brodie Park South: Copy Of Letter To Residents

By: Maria Moore

The Friends Of Brodie Park South (FOBPS) have mailed hundreds of letters to town residents, expressing their support for the Recreation Commission as that Commission is in the process of revising the town’s park rules, while at the same time expressing their concern at the undue pressure being exerted by the First Selectman’s Office to rewrite the park rules to permit Football to continue practicing at Brodie Park South as they did last year, under their own self-made rules while ignoring Rec’s park rules and Rec’s request for that group to move to a more appropriate practice space at one of the town’s elementary schools.

The FOBPS letter gives specific examples of how Football’s use of Brodie Park South last year broke many of Rec’s rules, the very rules that have guided all residents’ use of town parks for the past 25 years.  Rec has made exceptions to their rules whenever necessary to accommodate the changing needs of individuals and groups within the context of the community’s need as a whole to access and enjoy the town’s parks. The FOBPS letter invites residents to watch the video of the Rec Commission’s March 7 meeting at which the Rec Commission members discussed the unacceptable use of Brodie Park South by Football and their reaffirmation that their park rules apply to all groups and all the town’s parks. After the First Selectman exerted pressure on Rec to rewrite their park rules, Rec set up a Committee that is now working on reviewing and revising the town’s park rules. In their letter, the FOBPS encourage residents to let their voices be heard by contacting the Rec Commission members, the First Selectman’s Office and by contacting the FOBPS directly.

Below is a copy of the letter that has already been received by many town residents; you may also download a copy of the FOBPS letter: FOBPS letter, March 24, 2012 (26).


The open field area at Brodie Park South photographed in May 2010, when the Brodie Park South Environmental Baseline Report was made public. The report was commissioned by the Brodie Park South Group/Committee to help its members come up with a recommendation of the best use for Brodie Park South. That committee has almost completed its work and their recommendation to the Rec Commission will be made shortly. Photo: NewHartfordPlus archives

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.0 Comments

‘Wolverines At Work’: Snapshot

‘Wolverines At Work’: Snapshot

We received the following photo from Steve Roth, President of New Hartford Football & Cheer, showing members of the Wolverines this past Saturday morning, December 2, at Brodie Park South helping to repair the damage to the field area where several trucks had gotten stuck while attempting to retrieve their program’s storage POD in the park.  Steve emailed us his consent for us to use the photo of the players on NHPlus and he added: “I appreciate your crediting NHYFC for its responsible stewardship of the playing fields that we all value so much.”

Members of the Wolverines and their families helping to repair the damage at Brodie Park South. Contributed photo courtesy of Steve Roth

HUGE Thanks” to the Wolverines and their families for helping to restore this town park to a condition where it may be enjoyed by all. Happy Holiday, everyone! The NHPlus Crew

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S., Photos5 Comments

A Very Bad Day At Brodie Park South: Photojournal

A Very Bad Day At Brodie Park South: Photojournal

Photojournal By: Maria Moore

Yesterday (Monday, November 28) was a very bad day at Brodie Park South, as these photos show.

Afternoon Through Evening Activity

.
At approximately 3:30 p.m. a concerned resident called the NewHartfordPlus crew to ask us to investigate some unusual activity taking place in the field area of Brodie Park South. The NHPlus crew made several trips to the park throughout the evening and the following photos are of the activity they saw unfold during the afternoon, evening and night.

The activity in the field area of Brodie Park South at approx. 3:30 p.m.

The flatbed truck that sank into the field area on its way to pick up the storage structure (POD) still in the park that was used this past summer and fall by the football program

The two truck drivers try to free the flatbed truck with chains around the tree without success

With dusk falling, the flatbed truck is still firmly stuck

The head of the football program responsible for the storage POD in the park arrives to assess the situation

With the light fading fast, the decision is made to bring in additional help

The head of football drives his car down the field to try to tow the flatbed truck

At 6 p.m. a pickup truck drives onto the field and tries to tow the flatbed truck without success

Night Activity

.
The NHPlus crew left the scene at approximately 6:30 p.m. and headed back to Brodie Park South at approximately 7:30 p.m. just in time to see the local constable’s pickup truck and a state police car leaving the parking lot. No other official presence was noted at the scene until First Selectman Dan Jerram arrived at approximately 9:30 p.m. It was unclear how long he remained on site.

At approximately 7:30 p.m., a second vehicle, a tow truck (on the right), had also gotten stuck in the field area of the park as it tried to tow the flatbed truck (on the left) out of the field

The tractor trailer leaves the Brodie Park South parking lot to go down Niles Road a hundred yards or so to position itself to tow the stranded vehicles out of the park

The lights inside the park as seen from across Niles Road, with the tractor trailer approaching (on the left)

The tractor trailer backs up Niles Road as one of the drivers directs traffic around it

At approximately 10:30 p.m. the tractor trailer had managed to pull the tow truck almost to the edge of the park

The NHPlus crew had to leave the scene at approximately 10:30 p.m. with the tractor trailer working on pulling the vehicles out of the park. By 12 midnight a Friend of NewHartfordPlus who happened to be going by the park reported that there was no visible activity at the park.

The large tractor trailer at 4 p.m. in the Brodie Park South parking lot. Seven hours later, this machine was used to pull out of the park the two vehicles that were stuck in the field area

The Morning After

.
This morning, Tuesday, November 29, the NewHartfordPlus crew went up to Brodie Park South and took photos and shot a video of the damage to the field area resulting from the activity there yesterday. Following are a few of those photos. The video will be posted as a Commentary by Maria Moore since she narrates the video and – yes – comments on the content.

The logs were removed from one of the access areas to the fields to allow the tow truck and the flatbed truck to be pulled out of the park

The troughs left behind as the two stranded trucks were pulled out of the park

The damaged area looking out towards the upper field at the park

A cell phone 4.75" high gives an idea of the depth of the troughs

The view from the bench where the flatbed truck had been stuck

The storage POD at Brodie Park South, the morning after the flatbed truck, the tow truck, the tractor trailer and other vehicles had left the park

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.22 Comments

Selectmen Meet, Discuss Recent Storm, Funding for Sports Fields And Stewardship of Town Parks: Videos

Selectmen Meet, Discuss Recent Storm, Funding for Sports Fields And Stewardship of Town Parks: Videos

Video Segment 1: Operations Update

.
At their Regular Meeting on Tuesday, November 22, First Selectman Dan Jerram gave a series of updates, including a report on operations related to the recent snowstorm and resulting power outage. In this first video segment, the Board also discusses a property transfer at RRDD1.
.

Video Segment 2: Opportunity for Public Input

.
In the second video segment below, Dan Eddy, Chairman of the Brodie Park South Study Commitee, requests $1,800.00 for studies of three potential sites for future sports fields. First Selectman Dan Jerram also discusses a letter received from the Conservation Commission concerning the Commission’s role in the stewardship of Town property. Later, a resident expresses concern about a lack of support services for Senior Citizens as highlighted by the late October storm.
.

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S., Video0 Comments

UPDATE: Letter Was Discussed!  When In Doubt, Post It:  An Item That May – Or May Not – Be Addressed At Tonight’s Selectmen’s Meeting

UPDATE: Letter Was Discussed! When In Doubt, Post It: An Item That May – Or May Not – Be Addressed At Tonight’s Selectmen’s Meeting

UPDATE: First Selectman Dan Jerram did discuss the letter from Conservation Chairperson Alison Murdock and noted that no trees have been cut at Brodie Park South and that any changes made at Brodie Park South are “miniscule and don’t have any impact.” [...]

____________________

At the same time that the Conservation Commission members sent a letter to the Planning and Zoning Commission members regarding their concerns about this past season’s use by a regional football program of Brodie Park South (see our November 21 article which included that letter), they had also submitted a letter to the Board of Selectmen.

With the Board of Selectmen’s Meeting set for this evening at 7 p.m. and no agenda for that meeting having been mailed to us through this morning, our reporter made two trips down to the First Selectman’s office, one at 8:10 a.m. and one at 1:15 p.m., to request a copy of the agenda, a copy of the Conservation Commission letter and also to ask whether that letter would be discussed at this evening’s meeting. Both times our reporter was told that only the First Selectman knew what he would be addressing under Correspondence at this evening’s meeting. Our reporter said that there were residents who would want to come to the meeting if the Conservation letter was to be discussed and the response was: “Let them come to the meeting and they’ll know if it’s going to be discussed!”

That is the message for the 20 or so concerned residents who showed up for the Planning and Zoning meeting yesterday evening and who would plan to attend this evening’s Selectmen’s meeting if they knew for sure that their issue, as represented by the Conservation Commission members, would be discussed.

So, when in doubt, we’ll post it: Below is the letter from the Conservation Commission members to the First Selectman which he may or may not include for discussion by the Board at this evening’s meeting:

Reporter’s Note: “Unbelievable” someone exclaimed at Town Hall as our reporter left the building. And she couldn’t agree more: Absolutely unbelievable to think that residents have nothing better to do than to go to meetings on the off-chance that their issue would be discussed. That’s why there are agendas for meetings.

A member of the town's Highway Department cutting the meadow area on September 28. Photo: Maria Moore

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S., Meetings0 Comments

Review Of Revised Regs., Discussion Of Conservation Commission Letter Of Concern Re. Brodie Park South On Tonight’s P&Z Agenda

Review Of Revised Regs., Discussion Of Conservation Commission Letter Of Concern Re. Brodie Park South On Tonight’s P&Z Agenda

This evening’s Planning & Zoning Special Meeting will be attended by both the Town Planner, Marty Connor, and the Town’s Land Use Attorney, Mark Branse. Both experts will be on hand to help the town’s Planning and Zoning Commission members as they review the final draft of the town’s zoning regulations before those revised regulations come into effect.

Both experts will also be on hand to participate in the discussion of the letter submitted to the Planning and Zoning Commission by the Conservation Commission regarding their concerns about the on-going, non-conforming use of Brodie Park South.  Download a copy of the Conservation Commission letter: Conservation Commission letter re. Brodie Park South, Oct. 28 2011 (107).

Specifically, the members of the Conservation Commission expressed the following concerns in their letter:

  1. The unpermitted use of the field area by a regional football program, i.e. no Special Exception was obtained to erect goal-posts, store equipment lockers, lights and tires on the property, and occupy the park after dusk;
  2. The activity described in (1) above was against the recommendations of the natural resources study done last year for the ad hoc Brodie Park Study Comittee;
  3. Safety and liability issues that the used described in (1) above has given rise to, e.g., the risk of injury by having an overflow of cars on a winding, back road and occupying the park after dark in violation of posted rules;
  4. Complaints and inquiries filed by residents with the Zoning Enforcement Officer, which according to those residents have been ignored, or answered with unofficial verbal reassurances rather than a written response.

Also attending this evening’s meeting will be a newly-formed group of town residents, the Friends of Brodie Park South, which will be supporting the Conservation Commission’s letter.

Also see our editor’s November 13 editorial When A Storage Structure Appears In A Neighborhood Park… which addresses some of the same concerns raised by the members of the Conservation Commission.

This will be the first meeting at which the Planning and Zoning Commission members will be hearing the concerns of a fellow Commission’s members and those of a residents’ group regarding the use of Brodie Park South by an active recreation group that has not not gone through the permitting process that other active recreation groups have had to follow to conduct their activities at other town parks.

Cars parked along Niles Road at Brodie Park South as dusk begins to fall during football practice on August 18. Photo: Maria Moore

______________________

The agenda for this evening’s Planning & Zoning Special Meeting is as follows:

PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2011
NEW HARTFORD TOWN HALL – 530 MAIN STREET

Agenda

1.Review of Draft Regulations with Town Land Use Attorney and Town Planner.
2.Review proposed changes to the Subdivision Regulations to be in compliance with Public Act 11-79 Bonding
3.Review proposed changes to the Subdivision Regulations to incorporate low impact development.
4.Discuss and review letter dated October 28, 2011 from the New Hartford Conservation Commission regarding Brodie Park South/football.

Respectfully Submitted,

Rista Malanca, CZEO
Zoning Enforcement Officer

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S., Meetings0 Comments

Editorial: When A Storage Structure Appears In a Neighborhood Park: Enforcing The Town’s Zoning Rules

Editorial: When A Storage Structure Appears In a Neighborhood Park: Enforcing The Town’s Zoning Rules

By: Maria Moore

Six weeks ago I filed a complaint with the Zoning Officer.  The complaint addressed a simple matter, or so I thought.  It was regarding a storage unit which had appeared in a town park in a residential neighborhood and which nobody seemed to know anything about.  It’s not that it’s so small that you wouldn’t see it: A metal structure approx. 10 ft. x 14 ft. with bright yellow stickers on it sitting in the corner of an open field must have been noticed by at least the town crew which was up there quite often, cutting down limbs from the trees, mowing down meadows  and keeping the grass on the field nicely clipped.

I checked with Rec – which normally has a say on what is placed in a town park and for how long – but this time, Rec didn’t know anything about it.  This led me to the Zoning Office to ask about the storage pod and how it got to that park and the answer was rather surprising: “I don’t know where that park is,” our Zoning Official replied, adding:  ”Unless I have a complaint, I don’t know anything about it.”  Hearing this, I filed a complaint stating:

“Pod left on town land w/out zoning approval, stadium lights use after dusk in town park without zoning approval.  My personal complaint as a resident.”

I filed this complaint in person on Thursday, September 29, and as of today, Sunday, November 12, I have yet to receive a response.  Practically every week I’ve stopped into the Zoning Office, only to be told the complaint was being worked on.  After 6 weeks, I asked specifically what was being worked on since, to me, it seemed a pretty cut-and-dried question: Is the storage Pod (an accessory building or structure in Zoning parlance) legally located in the town park or not?

“It’s really much more complicated than that!” I was told.  ”It all depends on whether the use that it’s an accessory to is legal or not, and that is what I’ve been working on,” the Zoning Official responded.

And that led me to read through the zoning regs, and ponder awhile and make a couple of calls to others more familiar with the regs than I am.  And the answer, it appears, is as simple as I had thought: Whether the use that it’s accessory to is legal or not, the structure requires a permit. Of course, if the use at the park is itself illegal, then a special exception would have to be obtained before any permit could be obtained, before any storage pod could appear in the town park.

The pod is still there, although the use that it’s an accessory to has ceased.

The stadium lights at the park; a resident's home is in the right of the image

And as for the floodlights mentioned in my complaint?  They were in use in that residential zone 4-5 times per week for a couple of months, without any zoning approval.  They are now gone, as they were last year at this time.  But come next summer, will they return again?

Residents depend on zoning regulations and the officials they hire to enforce them to safeguard their neighborhoods from inappropriate usage.  In this particular neighborhood, the inappropriate usages have been allowed to continue for months with no interference from Zoning – or any other town agency one would normally expect to respond to inappropriate usages that disrupt a neighborhood for months.

This inappropriate usage took place at Brodie Park South from August through the end of October.  Brodie Park South is in a neighborhood that is zoned residential.  The inappropriate usage could just as easily have happened at Chapin Park, or Callahan Park or at Brodie Park North, all in residential zones.  The zoning regulations apply there too, but would they be enforced in a timely way?

The storage structure that appeared in the town park three months ago is still at the park today, Sunday, November 13. Photo: Maria Moore

 

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.4 Comments

Some Thoughts About Brodie Park South, New Hartford

Some Thoughts About Brodie Park South, New Hartford

By: Paul Carrier

I was told many years ago about a piece of land situated in New Hartford that had a wonderful open area of fields and trees. Being an avid bird watcher I thought I would go see what this parcel of land was like. Since, I have visited these park lands often, and found them a jewel of open space for not only birds, but many forms of wildlife as well. The State of Connecticut has lost many valuable acres of open space lands through the years to development and reforestation, and any open spaces of land we have left are valued as prime important areas to conserve for the future of our States’ open space lands. Brodie Park South is one of these jewels.

A humming bird (?) in the meadow area, August 18, 2011

A most important aspect of these lands at Brodie Park are their uncut fields left to grow through the spring, summer and fall. By being so, the open uncut acres grow with vigor the essential plants that many species need to breed, feed and live in. Just to mention a few:

Butterflies of many species breed and feed here throughout the year.

Bees and other nectar feeding species – (of which there are so many) that are so important to pollination of wild, as well as domestically grown plants, trees and shrubs.

Birds – of which many are on the States’ endangered or special interest list.

7 Hawk species – (resident and migration) have been seen here utilizing this open areas for hunting of food, they are: Red-tailed hawk, Red-shouldered hawk, Broad-winged hawk, Goshawk, Sharp-shinned Hawk, Cooper’s Hawk, Northern Harrier, Kestrel, Merlin, and once a rare Peregrine.

Ruby-throated Hummingbird – often utilize the abundant flowers that grow here.

Wild Turkey – Also feed in the fields eating insects and seeds.

Ruffed Grouse – an ever-endangered species here in CT, I have seen several times feeding at the wood edge to these fields.

Many species of Flycatchers and other bird species use these open spaces to feed from.

Eastern Meadowlark – a rare breeder here in Connecticut, was once seen here in the spring. Maybe one year a pair might nest here.

Bobolink – another rare breeder here in Connecticut, were seen here during fall migration, with hopes some day of attracting a pair to nest.

Eastern Bluebird – nests here each spring, with more boxes we might even see more.

Sparrows of many species nest and feed here in the fields for seeds. Some nest here such as-Song, Chipping, Field Sparrows.

Savannah Sparrow – another vanishing breeding species here in Connecticut, that I have seen here in the spring, with a possible nester in 2007.

In addition to the many unique species that live and breed at Brodie Park South, there is another group of species that utilize this valuable area during their migrations for food, safety and rest. The abundance of open field food crops here for wildlife, especially during the fall and winter seasons is most valuable. Some of the more interesting wintering or migratory bird species that I have seen here in the past are:

Saw-whet Owl – Over wintering in the numerous coniferous trees on the property. (Other resident Owl species winter in these trees here as well.)

Nighthawks -not a hawk, but a northern migrant bird that passes through here in the fall, that is often seen here flying about catching insects.

5 species of Swallows – often seen here in the fall and spring migration feeding on the wing for insects.

Both Crossbill species have been seen here in the winter eating from the abundant cone crop. Also Redpolls and Siskins seen eating from the tall weeds of the field.

The uncommon Lincoln’s Sparrow regularly passes through Connecticut in the fall and spring, and these open fields have attracted them to stop and feed every year. I saw 7 individuals here last fall in one day – a 50-year record for me here in Connecticut – previous was two!

Several years in a row, the rare Vesper Sparrow was seen here in the spring, with hopes of nesting here some year.

Also, the many acres of forested lands at Brodie Park South are also of much value to many forms of wildlife. But this is another story to be explored at another time.

I would like to suggest to the town of New Hartford, to try and see and appreciate the uniqueness and spectacular value of this piece of property, and to understand the necessity in keeping this property as it is. Your present plan to only mow the open wild fields only once a year is such a gift to the many animal, bird and plant species that utilize these vanishing open fields for food, to breed in and to feed the many forms of life that pass through here each year. Any change or future development to these lands would be a devastating blow to so many species and vanishing life forms that now inhabit these lands.

I personally consider these open fields a precious gift to not only the wildlife that live and feed here, but to the people who know their value as a place to see nature at its best, and have these acres to walk and enjoy as great open spaces that calm the mind, energize our senses and afford us the space to contemplate nature at its best.

A little about myself: I am 67 years old, have lived in Harwinton CT for over 35 years, and recently retired from the Advertising field as an Artist, Illustrator, Graphic designer. I am married with 2 children.

I have been a life member since 1972 of the Hartford Audubon Society, and have led many Birding field trips for this Organization. I also write articles about birds for the Hartford Audubon, plus the COA (CT Ornithological Association’s Journal and Newsletters). Through the years I have given many talks to interested groups on many subjects, including land preservation. My primary interests today is for the preservation of our vanishing open spaces, which are being lost at an alarming rate, adding many bird and other life forms to the States Endangered list.

A view of the meadows at Brodie South looking south, August 11, 2011

The meadow area bordering the interior field used for football practice, August 17, 2011

The meadow extends up to the bench overlooking the interior field, August 23, 2011

A view of the mowed meadow area alongside the interior field used for football practice, September 14, 2011

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.1 Comment

REPORT COMPLETED: Neighbors, Friends Of Brodie Park South Express Concerns To Selectmen At August Meeting

REPORT COMPLETED: Neighbors, Friends Of Brodie Park South Express Concerns To Selectmen At August Meeting

By: Maria Moore

Following is a report of the Public Comment section at the beginning of the Board of Selectmen’s agenda for the August 23 meeting. For the complete and official minutes of that meeting, please visit the Meetings and Agendas section of the Town’s website. The minutes of the Selectmen’s meetings are not submitted to the Town Clerk until they have been approved during the following month’s meeting. For questions regarding the unapproved minutes please see Christine Hayward in the First Selectman’s Office.

The August 23 Board of Selectmen Meeting, with two of the three Selectmen at the meeting – present were First Selectman Dan Jerram and Selectman Tom Klebart – began with a half-hour executive session, during which about two dozen members of the public waited patiently in the hallway or in the Town Hall employees’ staff room. The large public turnout – usually there are no more than a couple of residents at the meetings – was due to the Brodie Park South issue, especially the planned cutting down of trees and the cutting of the lower branches of trees around the area currently being used for football practice; see our September 1 report on the Brodie South Study Committee meeting where these issues were addressed.
By: Maria Moore

Once the public was allowed into the meeting, First Selectman Dan Jerram passed around a letter and some photos addressing the Brodie Park South maintenance program which he said he had undertaken last summer after the Town’s highway crew expressed their concern at the condition of the trees which had been overtaken by bittersweet and grapevines; download a copy of that letter: Dan Jerram letter re. maintenance of trees at Brodie South (71).

The First Selectman said that Don Birden, the member of the crew that takes care of “South Brodie,” has taken great care in the improvements that have taken place. He said the town has an employee on the crew who is a licensed forester and he is happy with the work that is being done. “The approach is working and the trees are being saved.” Dan Jerram said. He then opened the floor to the public.

A neighbor of the park said she disagreed with him. She said that she too had spoken with a forester and added: “I am sure there are other ways to save the trees than to cut the bottom branches and change the form of the trees.” She said the trees don’t look as good now that the branches don’t reach the ground and that lots of people are shocked at what they see. “You can cut the vines from the base.” She suggested.  She also disagreed with the First Selectman’s statement that only 4-5 feet of the lower branches had been cut. “I’m 5 feet 4 and I stood under those branches and you could fit another me underneath.” She then read a letter from a retired forester, who registered his concern at the occurrences at Brodie South and who said: “…I respectfully request and urge the town of New Hartford to limit pruning to dead trees or branches and make every effort to keep Brodie Park South green and beautiful…” Read a copy of the letter posted on NHPlus on August 23, the day of the meeting. The resident said that the members of the Brodie South Committee were asking to stop the tree cutting activity until they conclude their study. “Why not utilize the Committee where people have volunteered to do the task?” She asked. The resident also said that she and others would volunteer to form groups to go in and cut the vines at no cost to the town.

Another resident commented: “If we have someone on staff to take care of the trees and the vines on the trees have been left to a point where there’s damage to the trees I would ask ‘Where have you been?’ ” “I would say there has been a lack of appropriate management.”  The First Selectman answered.  The resident then went on to suggest that the town set up a schedule of maintenance of trees in all parks and that they hire someone who is an expert in trees who would as a routine  trim the trees and identify those to be cut.

A resident asked Dan Eddy, Chairman of the Brodie South Committee and a member of the Rec Commission, how tree maintenance was handled at Brodie North (where Berkshire Hall is located). Dan Eddy said that Brodie North has been managed by cutting dead and dangerous trees. Dan Jerram said that they still have had trees falling and that one had recently fallen on the Nurse’s cabin at Brodie North; he went on to say that there are some large spruces north of the parking lot at Brodie South that would have to be cut. Dan Eddy clarified that Dennis Minor, the Rec Director, alerts the selectmen about work that needs to be done. Asked who authorizes the tree-cutting, Dan Jerram said that there are four appointed tree wardens: himself, fellow Selectman Bruce Gresczyk, George Phillips and Brenda Schauffler; he said that he gave the direction for Brodie South and he said he believed it was working. Asked if there is an arborist on staff, Dan Jerram said that Brenda had taken some classes but he didn’t know the specifics.

Dan Eddy said that when Rec had worked on Callahan Park, on the banks of the Farmington River, they had been required by the Planning & Zoning Commission that they have a licensed individual come out and mark the invasives.

Dan Jerram went on to say that there were a number of dead trees at Brodie South that were scheduled to be taken down and that a couple of the spruces couldn’t be saved.  Regarding the cutting of the lower branches he said it helped Don with the mowing.  Dan Jerram said that there were more trees along the second practice field where the vines were so bad that the trees (on the other side of the trees from the football goalposts) would also need work.  A resident said again that the vines can be removed without cutting the lower branches.  Selectman Tom Klebart said that the nature of the Norway spruces is to have that lower canopy and he questioned whether one would want to have that canopy removed. “It’s a forest natural habitat and you’ve destroyed that.” A resident said, adding: “Your success is not what’s necessarily best for the park or the people. There are other options for handling these trees and there are other experts out there that could do this without removing that canopy and keeping things as nature intended them to be in their natural form and letting nature take its course and allow natural occurrences.” “Letting nature take its course is what caused this problem!” The First Selectman responded. Tom Klebart interrupted the exchange of differing opinions between the First Selectman and the resident by said: “The question is how to best maintain those trees while keeping their canopy.” The same resident agreed with Tom Klebart, saying: “We have volunteers willing to work on this. Why not confer with experts that are free and have them tell us how to do this without removing the base of the trees without changing the whole look of the park and the landscape?” The First Selectman said he appreciated the input and would take her suggestions under consideration.

Christine Hayward, the First Selectman’s assistant, volunteered her opinion on using volunteers: “I know there are a lot of volunteers out there that are willing to volunteer to cut vines, who are willing to work. I meet with the insurance company all the time and looking at our insurance coverage, whenever we have volunteers out there we have to know who’s working on things, who’s supervising them, and the insurance company says that when you put tools that could be dangerous in the hands of volunteers then you’re looking at a liable situation… That’s how our insurance company feels: Our insurance company goes crazy at that type of thing. Paul Mahoney and the boy scouts did a great job up there but once you start expanding and include well-meaning individuals who want to help, the insurance company gets a little nervous about that.”

The same resident responded: “Don’t you have the same liability when you open up the chain and let people onto the fields? They are not town employees. The chain is opened and there are 12 to 17 cars parked in the park and there are other trucks that go into the interior and they’re not town trucks.” “They’re not cutting trees.” Christine said. “Isn’t the town liable for anything they do and for any accidents they have?” The resident responded. “We’re talking about volunteers under the Conservation Commission and the Open Space Commission that know what they’re doing.” Dan Jerram’s response to this was: “I spent 8 years on the Conservation Commission.” Selectman Tom Klebart said: “I suggest we have the town crew do the work, but get a second opinion about what they should be doing.”

Another resident, who was a past chairperson of the Rec Commission, said that historically the town has had a very passive way of looking at the park. “We need to have the most people possible using that area because the more people use it, the more they’re invested in it.” She continued: “I don’t want this to become one group against another group. I am opposed to what is being done with the trees,” she said, going on to say that the natural environment such as is found at Brodie South is exactly why a lot of people move into New Hartford. “The question becomes when you’re mowing back for one specific group…” “We are not mowing back for any specific groups.” The First Selectman cut in. “We’ve mowed that area without having to get too close to the trees since I was Recreation Chairman.” The resident said. “Why do we suddenly need to change that because of a little bit of taller grass?” She said the area was being used right now by wildlife, the Boy Scouts, the schools, the people who walk there. “Let’s keep it for the most use, and not just say it’s for one particular group and discount it for use by bird lovers and nature lovers.”

Jack Casey, who is a Democratic candidate for the Board of Selectmen in the upcoming November election, said that it appeared to him that the lines of the pruning of the trees is aligned with the lines of the football field. “We never used to have lines in the field before and now we have lines,” Jack said. “If we’re going to talk about the maintenance of the park and of the trees, then maybe that should be part of our conversation. A lot of people here that I’ve talked to tonight are concerned about that we’re going too fast. I’m not saying it’s OK: We’ve improved the maintenance of the property because we now have football players there, which is great. It’s great that we were able – like we said, 30 years prior to cutting the trees, the trees were never cut. You’ve said yourself that it took years of neglect for these vines to overtake the trees. I just want to point out that there may be a connection between the maintenance of the park and the use of the property.” Jack Casey ended his input.

“They are separate issues.” Dan Jerram said. “And we have issues. We have growing pains: We’ve done dissertations on the sports usage, enrollment and the bottom line is we don’t have a place for them (football) to go. We’d like nothing more than to have a non-controversial place for them to go, but the bottom line is that we don’t. The tree issue has been going on since I’ve been here. This meeting has arisen quickly out of an issue that’s been out there for 18 months. The trees that are recovering now were pruned last summer. On average we’ve pruned one or two trees every other month. This is not a new thing.”

“But we’ve not pruned the trees in the previous 29 1/2 years?” Jack Casey asked. “No.” Dan Jerram responded. “I guess what I’m saying Dan,” Jack continued, “It’s OK to improve the property because of the additional use and that seems to be what’s happened. We’re taking better care of the property because we now have many of our fellow residents using the property.” “We have twice the population that we had 30 years ago.” Dan Jerram intervened. “And the constant is that we don’t have enough sports fields. Someone was told by the town that these trees were coming down.” Jack continued, pointing to a tree in the photo. “That tree may be coming down.” Dan Jerram said. “It’s marked to be pruned, evaluated and possibly removed. There are two spruce trees that have been marked with both colored tape.” “The person I spoke to articulated that all the trees were coming down, that’s probably why we have such a large constituency base here tonight. Is it true we have a committee to study additional sports fields in town? Jack asked. “Yes, but we have no guarantee of funding, we have no zoning approval. To have an honest discussion away from the trees to the sports use of South Brodie, we have a very nice group working with the Brodie South Task Force (Committee) that are trying to really design a program that will outline how we use South Brodie in the future and I think the Football folks have been very generous to be willing participants. We’d love to have a different home but we have no money and no zoning approvals so we have an uncertain future. We have really a make-do economy, make do with what you have. The possibility of going to our Board of Finance and say: “We’ve found an appropriate piece of land we need some amount of money, and then to go to P&Z and then for those neighborhoods to agree…” “I agree with what you say, but one thing I disagree.” Jack interjected. “Football is up there, that’s a constant event. For some of the people here, they’re wondering if they’re going to have the same use of the property that they have now. The football people – they have the use of the property now.” “Everybody has use of the property now.” Dan Jerram said. “Everybody is wanting the findings of the report, Football is wanting that information too, and everybody is wanting a plan but we all know that we have economy issues, money issues, and even if we get beyond those, we still have other elected officials on Planning & Zoning that would have to agree. The honest discussion is – we came here to talk about trees, but we have to talk about Football – the discussion is: If Football is an honest, interim use, how long is interim? I can’t tell you that. With no money, and nobody donating property and even if they did, with no zoning approvals, we all know that we have an uphill battle.”

Tom Klebart said: “Jack brings up a good point of why there are so many people here. What I heard when I came back from vacation a couple of weeks ago, everyone was saying the whole stand of trees were coming down.” Dan Jerram responded: “If you look at the stand of trees, a lot of the trees are coming down.” “What I heard is that the stand of trees were coming down to accommodate Football which I find is not the case.”

Jack then said: “The last thing I want to say is that I understand it’s hard economic times, but everybody here pays taxes, I pay my taxes. Let’s be careful what we say that we don’t have any money. We do have the money, we did purchase the property…” “I’m talking about an additional field if you talk about moving that group somewhere else.” Dan Jerram responded.

Our reporter, Maria Moore, then asked if the selectmen had received anything from the Brodie South Committee that had met the previous Thursday evening (see our September 1 report of that meeting). “I was at that meeting and they were going to send you an email asking you to stop all action at Brodie South while they are doing their evaluation. Have you received that?” “I have received that…” Dan Jerram began. “That’s your own appointed group that iss asking you…” “That was not appointed by this group.” She was corrected by the First Selectman. “They are doing the work of the town. Excuse me.” Dan Jerram picked up again: “They are not appointed by the Board of Selectmen, they are a a sub-Committee of the Rec Commission, and you’re starting to expand the scope beyond the realm of whatever they started to do, the future uses. The town has a responsibility to remove dead trees, to remove safety and liability issues.” Our reporter, answered: “Dead trees, yes. To prune them from the bottom, from the ground up which will ruin these trees forever more, no matter what else happens at that area…” Dan Jerram interjected: “That’s a subjective opinion. When we talk about future uses, we talk about active and passive, whether football would stay or not and how we would use the field, they were going to make a recommendation. I don’t think the scope from Rec included a tree by tree analysis.”

Rick Berneike, the Youth Sports representative on the Brodie South Committee, then said: “May I clarify that as a member of that Committee? Our concern was based on the rumor that a large stand of Norway spruces were going to be removed. That was our concern and that was the basis of our statement that if and until a plan of development came about for that property, the decision should be held off until that happens.” Dan Jerram asked: “So you would admit your group rendered a judgement on inaccurate information?” “That is correct.” Rick answered.

The resident who was a former chairperson of Rec then said that the town had originally gone before Planning & Zoning to approve how that acreage was to be used and it had been made part of the town plan, and she asked: “If we’re having a use that’s not part of that approved use, have you gone back before Zoning and said that we have a change of use?” Dan Jerram responded: “I wouldn’t differentiate between an organized soccer team and a football team.” The resident said they didn’t have permanent goal posts and risers. “I think we’re really digressing…” Dan Jerram said but the resident insisted: “I don’t think I’m digressing. The part of going before Planning & Zoning is a perfect opportunity for the Town to put forth the change of use and for every person to voice their concern and have the Town as a whole eventually make the decision on how that property gets used. I think that’s what a lot of people are concerned about, is how is that property going to be used and whether or not – maybe you don’t agree with us – but there’s a lot of people who think those trees in their natural state is the way it should be and we should be given a voice, the appropriate voice, to say so.” The First Selectman then asked if anyone else had input.

Another resident asked that the town get a second opinion from a professional arborist: “There are vines growing in there but it would be good if you could take the vines out without cutting off the branches. I don’t know if there is a way but let’s get an expert in there to see what he has to say.”

Our reporter, Maria Moore, then asked: “You mentioned there’s an arborist on the town crew..” “A forester” she was corrected. “Is that Mr. Birden himself (the town crew member who is in charge of cutting and pruning the trees)?” She ended her question. “No, that’s Steve (the forester on the town crew).” “I didn’t think so.’ She continued. “Has he been asked for his opinion on what is happening there?” “Yes,he has.” Dan Jerram responded. “OK, and was his input taken into consideration?” “Yes, I did ask him specifically what he thought of the pruning job that’s been done and he believes it’s benefiting the trees.” Dan Jerram responded. “I’d like to hear that from Steve himself.” She went on. “In the meantime, when you appoint tree wardens – and you mentioned four – how many of you have any real training? I know Brenda (Schauffler) attended a course. Does anyone else have any training as a tree warden?” “I don’t believe so – I don’t know, I can’t speak for the others.” Dan Jerram responded. “Shouldn’t that be required if you want to be a tree warden, shouldn’t you put yourself through a training course so that you do understand the different aspects of taking care of trees?” “There are no minimum requirements to my knowledge.” Dan Jerram responded. “There should be, there should be.” She responded.

A long-time resident of the town said that at the time the Brodie property was purchased: “Anita (Baxter the First Selectwoman at the time) showed us on a billboard that townspeople took on an extra payment of $150 per year for 20 to 30 years and for the duration that was our park. That being said, the Town voted to purchase the park under duress of higher taxes. If I’m correct, what you’re saying is you have to be open and notorious… ” “I’m sorry, I didn’t hear what you said?” Dan Jerram asked. “Open and notorious with what is happening with the trees and Football and Recreation.” “Open and…?” Dan Jerram asked, puzzled. “Open and notorious.” The resident repeated. “What do you mean by that?” He was asked. “Being open and notorious with what’s going on at the park. Because the people voted for that, it’s the people’s choice what goes on in the park, not yours. Your job is to guide the people and give that information of “here people of New Hartford, this is what’s going on, here’s the parameters that you have to work by” and let the people decide what goes on with the trees, Football and things of that nature.” The resident stopped and asked of Dan Jerram: “Why do you think it’s funny? You’re smiling.” “Dan Jerram, who had been smiling at the resident’s input, said: “I don’t think that you have surveyed the entire population just as this room can’t speak for the entire population.” “What happened when we voted for the park? We surveyed the park and everybody voted for it.” “Would you recommend a referendum for the trees?” Dan Jerram asked. “Absolutely, not for the trees. Keep it open for what’s going on. A lot of people don’t know this meeting is going on and they didn’t know the last meeting was going on and all of a sudden you go to one meeting and you find out all these other things that are going on. I just wish the Town would let everybody know what was going on. I have full confidence in the people of New Hartford and you should too.” The resident said. “I do.” Dan Jerram said. “And your job is to guide them, not to say “This is the way you’re going.” ” “I’d like to think that I do that. Great care has been taken over the long term to see that the trees have been taken care of, when many selectmen before me have chosen to ignore that responsibility. And I think that now maintenance of our parks is improving. We have problems, there is no doubt about it,but when I was on vacation, when there was uncertainty we told the guys not to cut, and we marked very carefully every single tree. Not that this was an imminent movement, this was a long-time, deliberative process here. It’s been going on since last summer and many people have complimented us on the work.” Dan Jerram said. The resident responded: “I think what we’re talking about there’s possibly correlation with Football, whichever is true or not. I’m trying to get down to the crux of the matter, is that what most people are concerned about, is that they are able to have input as they did in purchasing the park and hopefully you will note that, that that in itself, people voting to buy that park is a separate entity and now they have the right to decide what’s going on as the town grows and as you feel there’s no room for Football otherwise than at Brodie Park. Maybe other people have ideas. I’m just giving my opinion. Hopefully you’ll encourage answers for that.”

Dan Jerram said: “I think it’s important for us to recognize that we have a very deliberate approach. We don’t do things quickly on some of these larger issues and I think Don has been careful and slow and I think it’s unfortunate that through some level of lack of appropriate information people get upset and nervous. I think we have two separate issues of concern here: we have concern about Football and those folks are taxpayers, too, and we know that we have a glaring lack of improved field space suitable with parking and all those amenities, those uses are best left to our Land Use folks, I wouldn’t want to speak for them. But for practice we need to have more space, we need to have a plan for the future. Maria somewhere on her website has the video of the dissertation I gave of the numbers of how many play sports every day, they’d love to be down at Brown’s Corner every day… We have a lack of appropriate funds to move forward. Now we have new sports coming along – now we have spring soccer and fall soccer and spring baseball and fall baseball, and lacrosse is next and football…We have a filet mignon appetite and a cheeseburger budget… We have a group of people, the Board of Finance, who watch over our finances and guide us through these cautious times, you watch the job market, and the economy. People are hurting out there and I don’t think there’s the willingness to appropriate a large amount of money. Again, that would presume that even if we did have that ability and have those folks on board, then we’d still have to jump through hoops and go before our Land Use people, and that would presume that the folks in the new neighborhood would say OK.”

Another resident then gave her input regarding the trees. She said: “I’d like to hear from experts on both sides on how to take care of maintaining the trees. My problem is, if there are multiple ways of maintaining the trees, I think we need to go with the least obtrusive way of doing so because once you take down a limb 8 to 10 feet off the ground, they’re never going to come back. Why not start out as unintrusive as possible to do what needs to be done. Rather than having people chopping things down, have them go down there and cut the base of the vine and then go back and pull out the vine. We try to maintain the trees on our own property and cutting something, especially something that’s healthy or can be healthy, is a last resort. I hope that if you take nothing else from this evening you will take that to heart and know that no more should there be people taking the most aggressive means possible to take care of what’s wrong with a tree. We need to protect them and we need to do what is least invasive. You know, if you break your toe, you don’t have your foot removed. You don’t do that.” Dan Jerram responded: “I don’t think they’ve taken the most extreme route.”

The public input time was just about up, and anothe resident came in with his opinion: “I have to agree that when 5 feet or 10 feet is taken off a tree, that is not the least invasive approach. The point I want to make is I’ve been here for 13-14 years and the use of that area, Brodie Park South, is a thorn in the side of every resident and I’d like to see the issue put to bed through referendum what that land will be used for. Then the problem is solved for now and for future generations.” “I don’t know if that’s appropriate.” Dan Jerram responded. “That would usurp the authority of the elected Land Use officials. While you may be talking about referendum to permanently protect something, I don’t know that the Town is ready to do that. We don’t have a recommendation from the Task Force. I think there’s been some talk and we’ve had some discussions about possibly protecting some or all. I don’t know where the Selectmen stand on that, I don’t know what the Task Force will make a recommendation on, but then again, we also have growth issues, we have growing pains. Just like the people in this room have a right to an opinion of what is appropriate use, the people who aren’t here tonight who may have different opinions, also have a right.”

“Will you stop until you get recommendations?” A resident asked. “I’m going to consider tonight’s discussion and I’m going to have to think about it a little bit….” “There’s no rush, no recommendation have been made.” The resident said. “And we haven’t been rushing.” Dan Jerram said. “I hear different things.” The resident said. “Earlier in the evening you said you’re going to take some trees down as an aside.” “We are going to take some trees down. The trees that are marked for removal.” Dan Jerram’s cell phone rang and while he took the call, Tom Klebart said: “There are some trees that are dead and will have to come down.” “I agree, but there are a lot of trees that are not. And again, what’s the rush? You don’t have a recommendation, you don’t have a plan, you don’t know if football is going to stay there so what is the point?”

Another resident then said: “Let me tell you how it could all be solved. I coached baseball for 14 years and I have tried to get it to safety. Can you tell me one other town that has a facility like ours with a town that supports it without lights? You could solve hundreds of problems with lights. Steve Wabrek was willing to donate his time and part materials to put lights down at Brown’s Corner. Every coach coaching baseball knows, there are so many times when the game goes just 15 minutes too long, and you’re holding your breath while a little girl is trying to catch a high pop. You could have softball, men’s leagues, you could clear out the schedule and I have suggested from the beginning that with a facility like we have at Brown’s Corner – but the Babe Ruth field, east to west, is the perfect spot for it and you’ve got to be able to move the soccer field around. Then you’ve got Brodie Park South and Brodie Park North, and a facility like Brown’s Corner, and we also have Antolini (school). How many people are in this town?” “6,970.” Dan Jerram responded. The resident continued: “I’ll treat you out to dinner if you can show me one other town that has a facility like we have (Brown’s Corner) with a small populace and now with these economic conditions we’re actually considering a facility at Brodie Park, a new facility that would be like a cash cow because if a football field is going into Brodie Park, that would mean – I want to be sure the whole town knows that – a regulation size field, and that would mean restrooms, lights, emergency vehicles, parking. So the whole Brodie Park South, if football goes in, is wiped out.” “You’ve really taken a leap far beyond where we are.” Dan Jerram said. “I don’t think anyone’s proposing a stadium. If anyone’s told you we’re putting up a Meadowlands…” The resident interrupted: “Could you think about the lights, Mr. Jerram? Just to help out at Brown’s Corner.” “That could be a touchy issue.” Dan Jerram responded. “It’s $10,000, I think it would well be worth the money.” The resident said.

Another resident brought the focus back to the trees at Brodie South, saying: “You stated that it was a slow process and that Don has been working on the trees for many years…” “Many months” the First Selectman responded. “Since there is no urgency, why not put it on hold and get the outside expert opinion that’s free to the town and you’ll please everybody.” “At least for the spruces.” Another resident called out. “Actually, for anything that’s there. They may be dead but I don’t see them posing a threat.” “They will be removed.” Dan Jerram said. “Well, hold off on the other one and utilize the resources we have available.” the resident insisted. “I’m going to consider tonight, and I’m going to think about it and I’m going to consider my position. I don’t know what I’m going to do. I have to act in the best interest of the town and that is the 25 people that have gathered here and people that haven’t had the opportunity to be heard.” With that, Dan Jerram called on the last person to speak in the Public Comment section. The speaker was a long-time farmer in town, and he said: “My comment probably isn’t worth tiddly-squat. I worked at Brodie Park probably 30 years ago. As a farmer I used to mow the golf course and I used to help the camp by mowing the field area. The trees I saw – I don’t know who took the photos – the majority of those trees are not healthy, they should come down, one way or the other. I’ve spent my whole life in the woods cutting firewood cutting back edges of lots and personally I like my trees cut about 10 feet high so you can drive in underneath them with the tractor. Nothing to do with the playground, it makes it a lot easier, a lot safer to work. You can cut those bittersweet down at the base of the tree, but if you pull the bittersweet you’ll tear limbs off that tree. And I think the Town is absolutely foolish if it lets people go in there and donating their time because somebody’s going to get hurt, guaranteed.”

Selectman Tom Klebart said: “I go back to my original suggestion to have another arborist take a look at it and then have the town crew do the work.” “It’s a good point,” Dan Jerram said. “Please consider it.” “I always do.”

The members of the public who had gathered to express their concerns regarding Brodie Park South left the meeting, and the selectmen continued on with their long agenda which has become a standard occurrence since they changed their meetings from twice a month to now meeting only once a month.

[This report is being written live in detail as some have requested us to do; Friday, Sept. 23]

Trees in the foreground that are tagged for maintenance. Photo: Maria Moore

Pine trees that have been tagged for cutting or to have lower branches cut. Photo: Maria Moore

___________________

Following is the agenda for the Board of Selectmen Meeting on August reported on above:

Board of Selectmen
Regular Meeting
Tuesday, August 23, 2011
7:00 PM
Town Hall
AGENDA
PLEASE NOTE THAT THERE IS AN EXECUTIVE SESSION AT THE TOP OF THIS AGENDA, IT IS EXPECTED THAT THE SESSION WILL LAST FOR ONE-HALF HOUR AND THAT THE MEETING WILL BE OPENED TO THE PUBLIC AT 7:30 PM.

1.) Minutes – July 26, 2011
2.) Executive Session – Re: MSW contract

3.)Operations Updates ( i.e. Road work, Road Grader, Field House Roof, Trees, and others)
4.) CRRA contract discussion
5.)Update re: Bill Case request for Boundary Line Agreement
6.) Update re: Volunteer Tax Abatement
7.) Stormwater Survey – West Hill Lake
8.) Discussion of items and possible dates for Town Meeting
9.) Proclamation re: Constitution Week
10.)Proclamation re: United Way
11.) Appointments/Resignations – Boards and Commissions
12.) Request for Tax Refunds
13.) Opportunity for Public Comment on agenda items
14.) Correspondence
15.)Any Other Business to Come Before this Board
Respectfully Submitted,

Christine Hayward, Administrative Assistant

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.0 Comments

Regional # 7 Board Receives Report On Regionalization Study, Gives Update On Growing Football Needs

Regional # 7 Board Receives Report On Regionalization Study, Gives Update On Growing Football Needs

By: Andrew Pelletier

The Northwestern Regional Board of Ed met on Wednesday, September 14. In attendance was Althea “Candy” Perez – Middle school Principal, Ken Chichester – High School Principal, Judith Palmer – Superintendent, Roger Newbury – Director of Finance, Molly Sexton Read – Chair and representative for Barkhamsted, Janice Dorazio – Vice Chair and representative for Colebrook, Rob Jerram – Representing New Hartford, Mark Lanctot – Representing Barkhamsted, Noel Gauthier – Representing New Hartford, Terri Kenneson – Representing Colebrook, and Deb Bell representative for Norfolk. Also in attendance were Senior, Lindsay Humphrey and Junior, Erika Gentile, representing the Regional 7 High School student body.

Following are some of the agenda items discussed at the meeting. For the official minutes of this meeting, when they become available, please visit the Board of Education section of the Regional 7 website.

2. Public Portion: Regionalization Committee Report

For electronic copy of the ‘Report on the Addition of Grades K-6′ produced by the Region 7 Study Committee please see our September 20 post Report On Regionalization By Region 7 Study Committee: Downloadable Copies Of Report & Appendices.

The Regionalization Committee (aka Region 7 Study Committee) had been convened by Regional 7 in the spring of 2010 at the request of two of its member towns, Colebrook and New Hartford, to study the addition of elementary grades (grades K-6) to Regional 7. The Committee was made up of two representatives from each of the Regional 7 towns, one from the local Board of Ed and one from each town’s Board of Finance, as well as a member of the Regional 7 Board of Ed for each of the member towns. There was also a state Board of Education member, Ronald Harris.

The New Hartford representatives on the Committee were Jennifer Zenuh of the New Hartford Public Schools Board of Ed (who was elected Chairman), Laura Sundquist from the town’s Board of Finance and Rob Jerram of the Regional 7 Board of Ed; see Appendix 6.14 of the report for the complete list of committee members.

Jim Millar presents the findings with Jenn Zenuh standing at the back of the principals

Jim Millar of the Colebrook Board of Finance went through a Powerpoint presentation of the Committee’s findings for the Regional 7 Board members. Also present was Jenn Zenuh, the chairwoman of the Committee. The report detailed pros and cons regarding the inclusion of grades K-6 into regional 7 which would include the towns of New Hartford, Colebrook, Norfolk, and Barkhamsted. Based on their findngs,  two motions had been put in front of the Committee members: the first, to “recommend the addition of grades k-6 to Region 7″ was defeated 8:1; however, a second motion stating that “regionalizing grades K-6 with Region 7 is inadvisable”, was approved 5:0,  but there were 4 abstentions. The Committee concluded that the abstentions reflected a sentiment that circumstances may change to favor the expansion of Region 7 in the future (see page 2 of the report).

Jim Millar summarized the reasons the Committee didn’t recommend regionalizing as follows:

  • The difference in the cost per student at the local schools meant that the larger towns of  New Hartford and Barkhamsted would have to subsidize the two smaller towns of Norfolk and Colebrook; the cost per student for New Hartford and Barkhamsted would increase while that of the smaller towns would decrease.uld decrease.
  • The regionalization of the elementary schools would not provide any major cost savings, when compared to the cost per student at Regions 6, 10 and 12.
  • Academic performance also wouldn’t benefit from regionalization since the Regional 7 towns’ test scores compare favorably with those of other regionalized K-12 school systems.
  • Many of the potential advantages resulting from regionalization have already been realized by the establishment of the Regional Superintendents’ Coordinating Council, the K-12 Curriculum Council, and Shared Services. Jim Millar pointed out that New Hartford was the only town that did not participate in Shared Services, which provides Special Ed services to the Region 7 member districts as well as other districts.

For an in-depth analysis of the costs per students, test scores, special ed services, etc. please refer to the ’Report on the Addition of Grades K-6′ which we will make available as a downloadable file once we receive a copy.

The Regional 7 Board of Education members thanked the members of the Region 7 Committee for their professionalism and thorough study.

The Region 7 Committee will be making presentations of their report to each member town. The date of the New Hartford presentation, which will be to the combined Board of Ed and Board of Finance, has yet to be established.

2. Opportunity for Public to Speak on Agenda Items

Maria Moore of New Hartford submitted a letter to the Regional 7 Board of Ed asking them to conduct a feasibility study to determine whether it would be in the best interest of the students at the Middle and High Schools to add a football field to the field space available to the Regional 7 Sports program. She told the Regional Board of Ed members that New Hartford had formed the Brodie South Study Committee that was looking into locating sites in town to accommodate a regulation-sized football field to be used initially by the Wolverines, a regional football program for 7 to 14 years with players form Norfolk, Winsted, Colebrook, Barkhamsted and New Hartford; the field would also be used to accommodate future youth sports programs, such as Lacrosse. The cost of developing such a field has been estimated to cost $200,000-$400,000 by the Youth Sports representative on the Brodie South committee. She told the Board members that the Chairman of that study committee had invited members of the community to explore other options and bring them back to the committee for consideration, and she had chosen to explore the option of having the field be part of Regional # 7.

The Chairwoman of the Board accepted her letter and said they would consider it and give her a response in writing as requested; dowload a copy of Maria Moore’s letter: Request For Feasibility Study For Football Field At Regiona # 7 (65).

5.  Old Business: GN Football

Later in their meeting, the Regional 7 Board gave an update on the Gilbert-Northwestern co-op Football program. There are now 31 players from Regional 7 out of the total 40. At 32 players or over, according to their association’s guidelines, the co-op must be dissolved and Regional will have to come up with some other arrangement for their football players. Regional 7 will be arranging a meeting with the football association to negotiate an extension while they come up with a solution. The Board agreed that there was no field space available at Regional; however, a Board member mentioned a farm near Regional that has been for sale for some time as a possible location for new playing fields.

The Board members agreed to continue exploring their options to accommodate Football at Regional.

4. Principals’ Reports

Candy Perez, Middle School Principal, said that everybody is settling in and adjustments to scheduling are being made. Seventh graders will also be taking a field trip to Boulder ridge for a day of trust, bonding and mentoring activities like zip-lining and rock wall climbing.

Ken Chichester, Principal of Regional 7 High School, announced that the year is off to a wonderful start and plans meetings with small groups of what he calls “school climate committees”. Students will be asked what they feel would enhance their learning experience and the quality of their learning environment. Issues vary from how kids treat one another and how some dress, to issues of bullying and intolerance. Mr. Chichester explained that one should be able to walk into the school and feel a positive school climate not only from the students but from the teachers and staff as well. He’s not only striving to have the best school climate in Connecticut, he wants to have the best school climate in the country!

On September 28th, the Highlander Fair will take place. Caps, gowns and yearbooks can be pre-ordered and there will be a number of vendors on hand. There will also be a Prescription drug disposal program available with a pharmacist and a police officer present. Bring in old, unwanted prescriptions and have them safely and securely disposed of.

5. Financial Reports

Roger Newbury, Director of Finance, reported that the school’s new oil tank has been fully approved, accepted and completed. New student parking has been created where they had available space for a few more vehicles. Permits have been obtained and within the next two months the school’s observatory will be put on its foundation and hopefully outfitted for star gazing before the first snows start to fly.

The Northwestern Regional # 7 Board of Ed with Superintendent Judy Palmer (in black suit), Business Manager Roger Newbury (next to Judy), and the two Student Council reps (on the far left)

______________

The agenda for the meeting reported on above was the following:

REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 7
BOARD OF EDUCATION
AGENDA

Wednesday, September 14, 2011
6:00 p.m.

Newbury Library-Media Center
Northwestern Regional High School\Middle School

1.0CALL TO ORDER

2.0 PUBLIC PORTION
2.1 Regionalization Committee Report
2.2 Opportunity for Public to Speak on Agenda Items

3.0 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3.1 Minutes – August 24, 2011

4.0 REPORTS
4.1 Student Representatives Reports – L. Humphrey, E. Gentile
4.2 Principals’ Reports – C. Perez, K. Chichester
4.3 Superintendent’s Report – J. Palmer
4.4 Director of Finance and Operations’ Report – R. Newbury

5.0 OLD BUSINESS
5.0 Updates
5.1 GN Football

6.0 NEW BUSINESS
6.1 Policy Review (First Reading) – #5113.2 Truancy

7.0 CORRESPONDENCE

8.0 OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEMS

9.0 EXECUTIVE SESSION
9.1 Negotiations

10.0 POSSIBLE ACTION ON EXECUTIVE SESSION ITEMS

11.0 ADJOURNMENT

Enclosures: Minutes – August 24, 2011; Policy Draft #5113.2 Truancy

[ The following are goals posted at the beginning of each agenda ]

Goals for Regional School District No. 7 Board of Education 2011-2012:
To stay abreast of 21st Century teaching and learning technologies that will equip students for future success.
To ensure existing programs, staffing needs and resources remain appropriate for Regional School District No. 7.
To continually assess Board of Education organization and operations.
To continue to expand and enhance communication to the public and community.
To continue to pursue advocacy for public education.

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.1 Comment

Saving the Landscape Character of Brodie South – Who Owns The Park?: Letter To Selectmen

Saving the Landscape Character of Brodie South – Who Owns The Park?: Letter To Selectmen

To: New Hartford Board of Selectmen: Dan Jerram, Bruce Greczyk, Tom Klebart

From: Jean Cronauer, member, Brodie South Study Committee

Re: Saving the Landscape Character of Brodie South – who owns the park? Is it the First Selectman, one interest group or all of us residents and taxpayers of New Hartford?

The Issue

Last week, August 8-12, members of the town maintenance crew reported to neighbors and other citizens that the First Selectman was planning and had directed them to cut the major stand of trees at Brodie South and mow more of the fields to facilitate expansion of the football practice area. An abutting neighbor of Brodie South has written to the BOS in opposition to these actions. Numerous citizens called or emailed the First Selectman about the issue.

However, none of the stakeholder groups such as Recreation, Friends of Brodie, Youth Sports, Conservation, Open Space Commissions have been informed, consulted or involved in any discussions or decisions regarding tree removal or changing the mowing schedule of the ground-nesting bird habitat.

Permanent damage to the natural resources of Brodie South is not justified to satisfy the needs of one park user (football) over the long term needs of many other park users: walkers, hikers, skiers, scouts, bird watchers, nature study, picnicers, dog walkers etc especially since football’s use of Brodie South is only temporary and seasonal.

Background

The Brodie South Study Committee was formed in 2010 to develop a long range plan for uses of Brodie South. At the time, there was interest in Brodie South from both Senior Citizens and youth football. An in-depth natural resource inventory of the land was conducted and can be found at New Hartford Plus.

Subsequently, the Senior Citizen Group formally withdrew their interest in a Senior Center at Brodie South in favor of a site at Brodie North with parking and infrastructure.

Members of the Study Committee represent the New Hartford Recreation Commission, Friends of Brodie, Youth Sports, Conservation Commission and Open Space Preservation Commission. Each group represented on the study committee drafted their position statement for uses of the park. Recreation Commission is on record as stating that Brodie South is not the best site for football fields. Friends of Brodie are on record as opposing athletic fields at Brodie South. Conservation has recommended the permanent preservation of the Park. Open Space has recommended a comprehensive long range planning approach for athletic fields that will secure enough land to meet long term town recreation needs.

In March of 2011, the study committee notified the townspeople via the Recreation Newsletter that Youth Sports was seeking “a large, well located flat parcel of land of 5-10 acres” for athletic fields.

The study committee currently has several properties under consideration for potential athletic fields. One of these is above Antolini School and one is a level well drained site in the south of town. Developing Athletic fields at Brodie South is seen only a last resort. The Paxton (highly erodible) Soils, slopes, public drinking water supply watershed, lack of infrastructure and narrow rural road all make development of athletic fields at Brodie South prohibitively difficult and expensive.

The issues raised by the neighbors demonstrate clearly that football is not a compatible use in a residential area such as Niles Road. Good planning requires sufficient buffering between such uses as exists at Brown’s Corner.

The youth football program is regional and enrolls children from surrounding towns. Football fields already exist at Torrington Middle School and at Gilbert School. Why should developing infrastructure for youth football be the sole responsibility of New Hartford? Lands at the Regional Refuse site could be jointly developed by New Hartford and Barkhamsted.

Natural Resource Value of the Trees at Brodie South

The stand of Norway Spruce Trees in question may be inconveniently placed for football practice; they are magnificently placed in the view of many others. Trees of this quality would be described as arboretum or estate specimens for their size, age and spread. They have been growing undisturbed for nearly 100 years or more all the while providing all kinds of benefits to us in New Hartford.

A certified forester who examined the trees on August 15, 2011 described them: “The Norway Spruce trees that have not been limbed have wide crowns that extend all the way to the ground and provide ground cover that is used by all sorts of wildlife. I saw piles (middens) of spruce seeds probably left by red squirrels, and a few burrows among the roots of the larger trees.

The uncut clump of spruce north of the football field and the goal posts contains the largest specimen tree, which is 35″ (DBH: diameter at breast height), about 100 years old, and just under 100 feet tall (95 feet), with a spread of over 40 feet. Some of the others are the same age or close, and some are probably younger.

I really love that part of Brodie, with its big wide-open spaces and wildlife meadows. The spruce trees are an important part of that because when I’m back in the meadows they screen the goalposts, port-a-potty, etc. I would hate to see them removed, or even any more pruning. “

These trees are absorbing tremendous amounts of water thus preventing the fields from being soggy and unusable. Removing them would permanently alter the hydrology of the site especially since the rest of the field has been compacted from mowing and traffic and does not drain as efficiently as the forested portion.

The habitat value of these trees for birds and a variety of other wildlife is immense. In addition they provide clean air for all of us and let’s not forget that all of these Ecosystem Services are provided every day for FREE. Their majestic scenic beauty and landscape value is irreplaceable.

Conclusion

In summary, the trees at Brodie South are a valuable town asset owned by us all. We all have a stewardship responsibility to protect and maintain their health. Our selectmen have a special fiduciary duty to preserve and protect town assets. It would be extremely irresponsible for one selectman to order removal of these trees to satisfy the demands of a particular temporary user group. There would be quite an outcry if a First Selectman unilaterally ordered the removal or destruction of another asset such as a town owned building. These trees are no less valuable an asset.

Protecting town assets is not simply “operational” as the office of the First Selectman stated to a neighbor. It is the valid responsibility of the entire BOS as well as the various land use agencies in town.

There is absolutely no valid reason to consider damaging or destroying these trees. Effective government must be open and good decision making results from a consensus of all interested parties. Our elected officials are required to represent the needs of all citizens and work in a transparent, collaborative fashion.

No permanent changes to Brodie South should be considered until the Study Committee finishes its work and reports its findings to the town.

____________________

Jean Cronauer is a resident of New Hartford. Jean is the Executive Director of the Northwest Conservation District.

The stand of trees in question are shown in the center of this image. Photo: Maria Moore

The meadow area at Brodie South which provides a habitat for birds, butterflies, bees and dragonflies, among other species. Photo: Maria Moore

Parking at Brodie South as dusk begins to fall during football practice which takes place from 6 p.m. until 8 p.m. three evenings per week. Photo: Maria Moore

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.10 Comments

Letter To Town’s Selectmen: Brodie South Neighborhood Disturbed By Increased Traffic, Noise, Shouts, Whistles, Horns, Lights, Generators & Garbage

Letter To Town’s Selectmen: Brodie South Neighborhood Disturbed By Increased Traffic, Noise, Shouts, Whistles, Horns, Lights, Generators & Garbage

Following is a copy of a letter from Janet Corey, a resident near Brodie Park South, which she sent to the Board of Selectmen and to Dan Eddy, Chairman of the Brodie South Study Group.  The letter enumerates the drastic change to the quiet of the neighborhood due to the use of the field area at Brodie South by New Hartford Football.

Pine trees with lowest branches cutJanet’s concern at the use of Brodie South for active sports activity deepened today when she learned from members of the town’s Highway Department – who were at Brodie South cutting the lower branches of the pine trees around the open field area – that they have been instructed by First Selectman Dan Jerram to cut down the stand of pine trees  behind the goal posts which separate the two open fields now being used for football practice.  The crew members have also been instructed to mow the meadow area adjacent to the fields throughout the summer rather than just once every September, as has been the case up until now.

[Note: We have replaced the original copy of Janet's letter with the one above which has had some misspellings corrected. This has been done at Janet's request; 6 p.m., Wedn. Aug. 10]

The stand of pines beyond the football goal posts which are scheduled to be cut down. A metal storage container has been added to the football paraphernalia left at the field area. Photo: Maria Moore

The meadow area that is scheduled to be mowed regularly rather than just once in September. Photo: Maria Moore

Posted in Around NH, Brodie Pk S.5 Comments

Community Calendar

See complete listings in our Community Calendar.


See flyers and calendars in our Bulletin Board.


See all local obituaries in our Obituaries Section.

Recent Comments

Note: We verify that all comments we receive include a valid email address. Please respond to our emailed reply to your comment so that we may publish it.

Community Videos

The Archives

Clear
New Hartford, CT United States
44°F
Clear
Humidity: 89%
Wind: NW at 4 mph